GD/PI / #GD Topic

April 04, 2017 @ 01:15 PM

desktop image
mobile image

April 04, 2017 @ 01:15 PM

Government can't take Credit for reduction in Oil pricing

  Published : Wednesday, 18 February, 2015 10:15 AM

After having cleared cut-off scores at MBA Institute, you will be invited for Group Discussion and now it is must for you to practice with variety of GD topics.
Read and develop points for discussion and make sure that you are concluding with conviction

Read GD Topic:

Government can't take Credit for reduction in Oil pricing

Time duration= 20 minutes

Number of participants= 5

Gurpreet Singh
The current BJP Government  at the Centre can certainly not take credit for reduction in Oil pricing. In fact, prices of oil as per barrel have fallen across the world. From a high of $110, it has now come down to almost $45 per barrel. Naturally the effects of the same will be faced across the world. To take credit for this reduction is definitely wrong on behalf of the Central Govt. and I do not support this move.

Chaman Lal

I agree with my colleague Gurpreet that reduction of oil prices is not just in India but across the world, for which the Central Govt. cannot be held responsible. However, what falls in BJP’s favour here is that this reduction has a lot of potential in boosting the economy. Manufacturing sectors can now increase their outputs and earn greater revenues, as they are the biggest consumers of oil. Though direct tax benefits can be passed to the consumers in countries such as India and America, consumers of countries such as Russia are likely to suffer, unless crude prices rise again.

Suman Thakral

I have a slightly different take on the entire issue of oil pricing. I feel that the Indian Government can take credit for price reduction, but not solely. Let me explain why- this is a time when the entire geo-political situation of the world is going through a change. China has become more democratic than communist, Russia now has Putin who is willing to change the way the world views it, and of course, India has witnessed the resurgence of the BJP which has surprisingly obtained the single largest majority. As a result of these, oil pricing has definitely been impacted. Between OPEC and the countries, there are mediators as well, just like in the vegetable market.

Jiah Alvarez

Where will companies such as Shell and British Petroleum go if prices of oil keep falling like this? Don’t you think they may just stop production and create an artificial scarcity of oil if unable to receive profits? Reduction of oil prices may be a blessing in disguise, but only to consumers in some parts of the world, not all. Credit for this cannot be given to India, but to Middle Eastern countries where bulk of oil is produced.

Mudassar Khan

Decrease in oil prices has directly stemmed from a drop in demand. Funding in emerging markets has decreased, which has indirectly also reduced the demand for oil. As a majority of the world countries are in debt at present, the reduction in oil pricing will only help meet the existing demand. Once again, the credit for this cannot be given to the Indian Govt.


By and large, most of the participants feel that reduction in oil pricing has nothing to do with contribution from the new Central Govt. In the current situation, it is a blessing in disguise since vehicle owners were generally suffering for the past several months. Apart from this, the Indian manufacturing sector will also receive a much needed boost, which will be bolstered by industry-friendly policies.

Stay informed, Stay ahead and stay inspired with MBA Rendezvous 

Crucial Dates, You Should not Miss

Manav Rachna International Institute
of Research

Admissions Open for all MBA programme at Manav Rachna International Institute of
Research and Studies.
CII School of Logistics Amity University, Delhi and Mumbai
Admissions Open at CII School of Logistics Delhi and Mumbai campus, Apply Now!
GITAM School of International Business, Visakhapatnam
Admissions open for MBA programmes at GITAM. Application Deadline is February 20, 2018
Application Last Date for Online Submission - February 25, 2018
FORE School of Management
Apply for PGDM & PGDM-IB Programmes. Admissions Open for 2018 Apply Now!
MDI Murshidabad
Applications for PGPM 2018-20 at MDI Murshidabad are open
Institute of Public Enterprise, Hyderabad
Last Date to Apply for IPE, Hyderabad is 17 February, 2018
IMI New Delhi
Admissions Open for Executive PGDM at IMI, New Delhi. Application closes on March 1, 2018.
K J Somaiya Institute of Management Studies & Research, Mumbai
Admissions Open for 2018 Apply Now!
Application for PGDM 2018-20 at SDMIMD is open till February 28, 2018
Birla Global University
Admission 2018 Open for MBA at Birla Global University
KIIT School of Management
Admissions Open for MBA at KIIT School of Management through CAT/ MAT/ GMAT/ ATMA/ CMAT/ XAT
TAPMI, Manipal
Last date extended to 11 February, 2018. Apply Now.