MORE / #General Awareness

April 04, 2017 @ 01:15 PM

Can GST Turn into a Tax System Reform?

Published : Tuesday, 14 July, 2015 11:22 AM

MBA aspirants must be updated with General Awareness on current topics. General awareness topics with analytically drawn conclusions will benefit you in CATXATIIFT, NMAT, CMATMAT, Essay writing General Awareness sections besides in WATGD & PI.

Read General Awareness Topic:

Can GST Turn into a Tax System Reform?

Currently being considered in the select committee of Rajya Sabha and awaiting passage, the Goods and Services Tax’s (GST) decade long journey has never had a smooth sailing. The intent to introduce GST, a uniform tax system across India, by April 1, 2010 was first mooted in the 2005-06 Union Budget speech by the then Finance Minister P Chidambaram.

Between now and then, the GST has missed deadlines, faced political turbulence especially from states, and undergone several rounds of revisions to suit India-specific conditions. The key question, however, yet remains unanswered: can it turn into a major overhaul of Indian tax system?

To be sincere, there cannot be a definitive zero-sum answer. The biggest irony with India’s biggest tax reform initiative in the post-independence period is: everyone agrees that GST is necessary, but significant differences upon the scope, form and content of the GST continue to prevail to this day.

It is necessary because nobody disagrees with the GST aim to replace a plethora of taxes (at least 14 central and state levies) with a countrywide uniform tax regime that promotes the cause of business and consumers alike. Despite that, GST has become a victim of political brinkmanship and vested interests.

For the uninitiated and in very simple terms, GST is an improved version of the Value-added Tax (VAT), which replaced the sales tax and has already been adopted by all Indian states. The difference between GST and VAT mainly pertains to widening the base of taxation.

While VAT is imposed only on goods, the GSK seeks to include services as well. To put it simply, GST is a VAT on goods and services. The existing tax regime allows states to tax sales of goods but not services, while the centre taxes manufacturing and services and not wholesale or retail trade.

The GST is, therefore, expected to usher in a uniform tax regime across India through an expansion of the base of each into the other’s territory. The two benefits of GST are, first, a simplified tax administration under GST likely will improve compliance, and remove economic distortions in production, trade, and consumption.

Second, by giving credit for taxes paid on inputs at every stage of the supply chain and taxing only the final consumer, it avoids the ‘cascading’ of taxes, thereby cutting production costs, and making exports more competitive. Finance Minister Arun Jaitley has reportedly said that the GST will add 2% to the country’s GDP due to these efficiencies.

Be that as it may, the political differences over GST largely stem from questions relating to the States’ fiscal, and therefore, political autonomy. To allay those fears in the short-to-medium term, the Constitution 122 Amendment Bill, 2014 passed in the Lok Sabha in May introduced a dual structure GST, levied and managed by different administrations. GST has proposed to subsume all the taxes levied by the Centre as Central GST (CGST) and all the state levies into one single tax called State GST (SGST). For all inter-state movement of goods & services, it shall be called Integrated GST (IGST) which shall have CGST and SGST.

The revenue neutral rate (RNR) has been plugged at 27% with CGST at 14% and SGST at 13%. The monitoring of compliance will also be done independently at the two levels. The government, however, in order to win support from states that fear losing revenue has agreed to a 1% additional levy by states on the cross-border transport of goods. There will be a separate tax on petrol, diesel and aviation fuel. All of this is in addition to compensation offered to states.

This back-room political manoeuvring by the BJP government to get GST rolled out in April 1, 2016 has raised concerns among businesses and industry bodies representing them. The discomfiture with the additional levies is that they tax even products to be transported between plants in different states and raise input costs for businesses, which is against the spirit of the reform. In fact, the Congress and other regional parties are backing businesses on this and want the levy to be scrapped along with the removal of exemptions on tobacco, liquor and electricity.

Many independent experts on the issue are not happy with the dual structure introduced in the Bill and would rather see delay than a hastily put reform creating tax chaos and high inflation. The proposed dual structure in reality may create a cascading five-layered tax structure which will be akin to miscarriage for the reform.

A multi-layered tax structure will further complicate the whole process of tax filing and returns for businesses. From the tax offices’ perspective, they will be burdened with complicated tax transactions, which will further undermine their already questionable capability to effectively oversee the tax administration process. The more than 25% rate of GST is unprecedented even by the European Union standards which levies a 19.5% GST rate. The world average is around 10-12%.

The GST aims to provide build a single market for India and the emerging grey areas in its implementation in current form suggest that more preparation is needed before it is rolled out. While the ruling government may believe that even a flawed reform could boost economic prospects of the country and evolve into an ideal GST regime, it must consider the fact that short-term gains could torpedo long-term goals of the reform.

Read More General Awareness Topic - PM Modi's South Korea visit

Stay informed, Stay ahead and stay inspired with MBA Rendezvous 

Crucial Dates, You Should not Miss

TAPMI, Manipal
Admission Application closes on January 16, 2018 for 2018-20
BIMTECH, Greater Noida
Admissions open for PGDM Programmes at BIMTECH. Apply Now !
Lal Bahadur Shastri Institute of Management
Admissions are Open at LBSIM, Delhi. Apply Now !
FORE School of Management
Apply for PGDM & PGDM-IB Programmes. Application Deadline is December 22, 2017.
Goa Institute of Management
PGDM Admissions Open at GIM. Apply Before January 5, 2018
NIRMA
Last Date to Apply for MBA (Full Time) Programme at NIRMA is January 09, 2018
XAT 2018
Application Last Date 30th November 2017
IMI New Delhi
Application closes 4th December 2017
XIM Bhubaneshwar
Last Date 8th December 2017
SIBM Bengaluru
Apply for SNAP 2017 to be held on Dec 17 and apply for SIBM-Bengaluru through the SNAP Form
Institute of Rural Management Anand
IRMASAT will be conducted on February 4,2018, Apply Before December 31,2017
IBSAT 2017
Last date for IBSAT registration is December 12 , 2017
SSBF
Last date to register for SNAP is 24th November, 2017. Last date for SSBF is 2nd January 2018
SIBM Hyderabad
Apply for SNAP 2017 to be held on Dec 17 and apply for SIBM-Hyderabad through the SNAP Form
K J Somaiya Institute of Management Studies & Research, Mumbai
Last date for Application is 31st Jan, 2018
SDMIMD Mysore
Application for PGDM 2018-20 at SDMIMD is open till February 28, 2018
Institute of Management Technology
Application closes on November 24, 2017
MDI Murshidabad
Application for PGPM 2018-20 at MDI Murshidabad is open till November 24, 2017

Admission Open Now

Following Colleges are accepting applications.

INTERNATIONAL MANAGEMENT INSTITUTE

Admissions open for 2018-20

PGDM, PGDM (HRM), PGDM(B & FS), Executive PGDM

Apply Online