General Awareness

April 04, 2017 @ 01:15 PM

GAAR : General Anti Avoidance Rules

General Awareness is knowledge of current affairs which is must for Cracking CAT 2012. 

Today you will read recent topic:  GAAR :  General Anti Avoidance Rules
 
Avoidance is an attempt to reduce tax liability through legal means, i.e. regulating tax related affairs in such a way that one pays the minimum tax imposed by the Act as opposed to the maximum. A general anti avoidance rule (GAAR) is a set of broad and general principles-based rules enacted in the tax code aimed at counteracting such avoidance of tax.
 
GAAR has been introduced in India due to Vodafone case ruling in favor of the company by the Supreme Court of India. The court had held on 20 January 2012 that the Income Tax department did not have the jurisdiction to levy Rs 11,000 crore tax on the offshore transaction between Vodafone International Holdings and Hutchison Group.  Supreme Court decision was followed by the government proposal, also known as GAAR, in the Union Budget 2012-13 providing for a “clarificatory retrospective amendment” in the Income Tax Act, with effect from 1962, to “restate the legislative intent” that overseas deals which derive their value substantially from domestic assets can be taxed. 
 
Under the GAAR provisions, the Tax Commissioner is empowered to declare an arrangement as an impermissible avoidance arrangement (IAA) if 
•The whole, a step or a part of the arrangement has been entered with the objective of obtaining tax benefit, and
•The arrangement
 
1)Creates rights and obligations not normally created in arm’s length transactions, or 
2)Results in direct or indirect misuse or abuse of the provisions of the code, or 
3)Lacks commercial substance in whole or part, or is not bonafide
 
Indian Government is trying to give powers to income tax authorities as implementation of GAAR provides tremendous powers to deny tax benefit to an entity if a transaction has been carried with the sole intention of tax avoidance. Due to powers in the hand of taxmen, now innocents may be harassed by them. 
 
Moreover, the Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) and Foreign Institutional Investment (FII) money coming to India through Mauritius route will become taxable. While in the worst case scenario, onus lies on the assesse to prove that there is no tax benefit and the transaction is not an avoidance transaction. 
 
GAAR can be invoked as an alternative to or in addition to any other basis of making an assessment. It is applicable even if the main / overall purpose of the arrangement is not to obtain a tax benefit and only if a step / part of the arrangement is to obtain a benefit.
It is also criticized for its ambiguous language, the lack of details, and the sudden onset of the provisions that among the factors that have upset foreign investors.
 
However, on 25 June 2012, former Union Finance Minister Pranab Mukherjee proposed to defer the rollout of GAAR by a year to the financial year that begins in April 2013 to "provide more time" to both taxpayers and the tax office to address all related issues. 
 
Moreover, in the light of above criticisms, he proposed some measures like-
 
•To remove the onus of proof entirely from the taxpayer and shift it to the revenue departments
•An independent member would be in the GAAR approving panel, while one member would be an officer of the level of Joint Secretary, or above, from the Ministry of Law
•On the proposed retrospective amendment in tax rules, the changes will not override the provisions of double-tax avoidance treaties India has with 82 countries. The retroactive changes will only impact those cases where a deal has been routed through low-tax and no-tax countries with whom India does not have tax treaties.
•The proposed retrospective changes in tax rules will not be used to reopen cases where assessment orders have already been finalized
•Non-resident investors of FIIs will be exempt from the rules, and there will be a monetary threshold from which GAAR will be implemented
•According to the draft, GAAR will come into effect from April 1 2013. According to the guidelines, FII not opting for treaty benefits and ready to pay taxes will not come under GAAR, but those who do opt for dual taxation avoidance agreements will come under its purview.
 
However, the rules of GAAR will be finalized after 20 July 2012 after seeking comments for other stakeholders. Ambiguities related to GAAR are needed to be resolved as soon as possible as it is likely to effect the FDI and FII which economy needs most at currently to upgrade its ratings. 
 
There is nothing wrong in a legislation which is aimed to curb the tax avoidance but such legislations must be designed to curb the tax avoidance only and not on strengthening the red tapism.    
 
articles on General awareness topics at MBA Rendezvous 
 

Crucial Dates, You Should not Miss

TAPMI, Manipal
Admission Application closes on January 16, 2018 for 2018-20
BIMTECH, Greater Noida
Admissions open for PGDM Programmes at BIMTECH. Apply Now !
Lal Bahadur Shastri Institute of Management
Admissions are Open at LBSIM, Delhi. Apply Now !
FORE School of Management
Apply for PGDM & PGDM-IB Programmes. Application Deadline is December 22, 2017.
Goa Institute of Management
PGDM Admissions Open at GIM. Apply Before January 5, 2018
NIRMA
Last Date to Apply for MBA (Full Time) Programme at NIRMA is January 09, 2018
XAT 2018
Application Last Date 30th November 2017
IMI New Delhi
Application closes 4th December 2017
XIM Bhubaneshwar
Last Date 8th December 2017
SIBM Bengaluru
Apply for SNAP 2017 to be held on Dec 17 and apply for SIBM-Bengaluru through the SNAP Form
Institute of Rural Management Anand
IRMASAT will be conducted on February 4,2018, Apply Before December 31,2017
IBSAT 2017
Last date for IBSAT registration is December 12 , 2017
SSBF
Last date to register for SNAP is 24th November, 2017. Last date for SSBF is 2nd January 2018
SIBM Hyderabad
Apply for SNAP 2017 to be held on Dec 17 and apply for SIBM-Hyderabad through the SNAP Form
K J Somaiya Institute of Management Studies & Research, Mumbai
Last date for Application is 31st Jan, 2018
SDMIMD Mysore
Application for PGDM 2018-20 at SDMIMD is open till February 28, 2018
Institute of Management Technology
Application closes on November 24, 2017
MDI Murshidabad
Application for PGPM 2018-20 at MDI Murshidabad is open till November 24, 2017

Admission Open Now

Following Colleges are accepting applications.

INTERNATIONAL MANAGEMENT INSTITUTE

Admissions open for 2018-20

PGDM, PGDM (HRM), PGDM(B & FS), Executive PGDM

Apply Online