The abrogation of Article 370 by the present-day Modi Government has divided the country. Some are for it and some against. With the Article 370 being scrapped, J&K will not enjoy any special status and the Indian constitution will be applicable to all its residents from now. Right to Information & Right to Education will be applicable and minorities in the region will l enjoy 16% reservations. Also, women from J&K can still retain their rights and citizenship even if they marry someone outside the state. While a certain sect is happy with these implications, many consider it as a threat to human rights and the Indian Democracy.
Here are the advantages and disadvantages of repealing Article 370 and Article 35A.
Advantages of Scrapping Article 370 |
Disadvantages of Scrapping Article 370 |
Attempts to unite Kashmir with other states of India. |
Instilled insecurity in the locals as they have to give away their dual citizenship |
Propagates One Nation One Constitution Slogan |
Kashmiri Muslims feel it threatens the state’s unity and integrity |
Open doors for growth and development in the valley |
Add on to the political vulnerability and instability in the Valley |
Private investors can invest and boost the economy of the state |
Hampers the delicate relationship with Pakistan. It is like a nail in the coffin |
Better medical and education facilities can be provided to the residents of the Valley |
Implants the seeds of insecurity in certain section of citizens. |
Central government can curb corruption since it is a UT now. |
The implementation of the abrogation of Article 370 is a threat to the democracy. It is an attempt to polarize and appease the Hindu population in the valley. |
Authorities are in a better position to curb terrorism and instill peace in the Valley |
Safety of Kashmiri girls is questioned. Certain Hindu fascists have threatened to marry girls of the region. This is outrightly sexist. |
The advantages and disadvantages can be subjective. We expect reader’s discretion.
Stay informed, Stay ahead and stay inspired withMBA Rendezvous